FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | White Elephant Gifts - Secret Santa

White Elephant Gifts - Secret Santa

Secret Santa got you down? Get your white elephant gifts from the experts! Gifts that are both stupid and funny! Sure to be a hit.
Sold Out
Furrybones Brady Sloth figurine, a skeleton in a brown sloth costume with large eyes and a stitched smile, hugging a small green sloth toy. The collectible combines cute and macabre elements in a whimsical design.

Furrybones Brady Sloth

$14.99
$14.99
Furrybones Bun Bun Bunny figurine, a skeleton in pink rabbit costume with long ears, holding a small white bunny toy. Features a skull face, stitched details, and blue polka dot tie. Cute and spooky collectible Easter decoration.

Furrybones Bun Bun Bunny

$14.99
$14.99
Colorful product packaging for Handisquirrel finger puppet set featuring a playful squirrel puppet on a hand against an autumn forest backdrop with falling leaves and trees

Handisquirrel - Squirrel Finger Puppet

$5.95
$5.95
Colorful glow-in-the-dark finger monsters in various whimsical designs, featuring different shapes, eyes, and appendages, worn on fingertips of a hand

Glow-in-the-Dark Finger Monsters

$9.95
$9.95
Finger Feet bulk box display with miniature rubber feet toys for fingers, showing packaging and product examples in various skin tones. Image showcases fun, novelty item for hands, perfect for creative play or tiny costumes.

Finger Feet - Bulk Box

$119.95
$119.95
Colorful display box of Terrifying Finger Monsters toy set featuring assorted miniature rubber monster characters in vibrant colors, designed for finger puppet play, with warning label for choking hazard

Finger Monsters - Bulk Box

$64.95
$64.95
Stuffed Space Needle plush toy, white and black, featuring iconic Seattle landmark design with distinctive observation deck and spire, perfect for Seattle lovers and souvenir collectors

Stuffed Space Needle

$9.95
$9.95
Green men's dress socks featuring brown Bigfoot silhouettes with red scarves, displayed alongside product packaging with matching design. Socks have dark green cuffs and heels, with visible branding on the foot.

Bigfoot Socks

$8.95
$8.95
Wind-up chattering teeth novelty toy with red and white plastic dentures, displayed next to its colorful retail box featuring bold text and playful graphics, perfect for gags and pranks

Wind-Up Chattering Teeth

$4.95
$4.95
Archie McPhee gift card design with orange logo, blue starry background, and text "Give the gift of awesome!" Perfect for quirky and unique gift-giving.

Super Awesome Gift Card

from $10.00
from $10.00
Glass ornament featuring a woman in pink robe and glasses with small cat figures, shown hanging and in packaging labeled 'Crazy Cat Lady Ornament

Crazy Cat Lady® Ornament

$16.95
$16.95
Set of 10 miniature hands for fingers, 5 right and 5 left, in light skin tone. Multiple tiny hands shown on two human hands, with orange text describing the product. Quirky and fun novelty item for parties and social media photos.

Finger Hands Light Skin Tone - Set of 10

$12.95
$12.95
Sale
Crazy Cat Lady embroidered patch packaging and product display, featuring a woman wearing a pink hat with the patch, holding a white cat, showcasing the patch's design with cartoon cats and a blonde woman icon

Crazy Cat Lady® Embroidered Patch

$2.50
$2.50
$4.95
Festive green sweater featuring Abraham Lincoln wearing a Santa hat, combining presidential history with holiday cheer in a unique and quirky design perfect for ugly sweater parties

Santa Lincoln Sweater

$42.50
$42.50
Whimsical glass Christmas tree ornament featuring a golden squirrel wearing white underpants, displayed in clear packaging with snowflake design and product name

Squirrel in Underpants Ornament

$16.95
$16.95
Whimsical unicorn squirrel feeder product display with packaging and demonstration image showing squirrel wearing unicorn head mask, creating magical backyard transformation illusion

Unicorn Squirrel Feeder

$18.95
$18.95
Li'l Devil's Trick of the Day prank collection featuring seven classic joke items including whoopee cushion, joy buzzer, nail through finger, trick candy, snapping gum, fake ketchup, and fly in ice cube, displayed on a circular card with individual items scattered around

Li'l Devil's Trick of the Day Prank Collection

$14.95
$14.95
Set of three Bigfoot-themed pocket journals with kraft covers featuring different Sasquatch designs, worldwide sightings map, and mountain landscapes. Includes an open journal showing a Bigfoot sketch and handwritten notes.

Bigfoot Pocket Journals

$6.95
$6.95
Colorful product packaging for Handicorn unicorn finger puppet set featuring a hand with white unicorn head and hooves against a vibrant rainbow and starry sky background, with grass and daisies at the bottom

Handicorn - Unicorn Finger Puppet

$7.50
$7.50
Blue triangular felt pennant with white text "GEEK" and a brain icon, perfect for proudly displaying geek status or support, ideal for IT enthusiasts and tech-savvy individuals

Geek Pennant

$4.50
$4.50
Set of three kraft-covered Grump Notebooks titled "Things That Annoy Me," "Daily Disappointments," and "Fresh Rants," displayed with packaging and an image of a disgruntled-looking older man wearing glasses and a red shirt.

Grump Notebooks

$6.95
$6.95
Bigfoot Research Kit contents displayed, including map, stickers, booklet, magnifier, and evidence flags, with decorated boxes showcasing Bigfoot illustrations and product details

Bigfoot Research Kit

$17.50
$17.50
Vintage Lord of the Rings character pins featuring Bilbo, Samwise, and Aragorn from the 1978 animated movie. Colorful circular metal pins with character illustrations and names on banners.

Lord of the Rings Pins

$6.95
$6.95
Golden Bigfoot Christmas ornament hanging from pine branch next to product packaging featuring forest silhouette and Bigfoot illustration

Bigfoot Ornament

$16.95
$16.95