FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Yellow and white striped Mac & Cheese Candy Canes in festive red packaging with snowflake decorations, featuring a smiling macaroni mascot. Box displays product name and weight, with two candy canes shown separately to highlight the unique color and twist pattern.

Mac & Cheese Candy Canes

$9.50
$9.50
Red and white striped bacon-flavored candy canes in festive packaging with cartoon pig illustration, snowflake design, and product name "Bacon Candy Canes" visible

Bacon Candy Canes

$9.50
$9.50
Set of 10 miniature hands for fingers, 5 right and 5 left, in light skin tone. Multiple tiny hands shown on two human hands, with orange text describing the product. Quirky and fun novelty item for parties and social media photos.

Finger Hands Light Skin Tone - Set of 10

$20.00
$20.00
$0.00
Ketchup-flavored candy canes in red and white stripes next to a festive ketchup bottle character. Box displays "Ketchup Candy Canes" with tomato flavor branding. Unique holiday treat combining Christmas tradition with unexpected condiment taste.

Ketchup Candy Canes

$9.50
$9.50
Best Seller
Instant Audience

Instant Audience

$13.75
$13.75
Best Seller
White Chinese takeout box with red pagoda design surrounded by red question marks, representing the Lucky Take-Out Surprise product filled with mystery Archie McPhee items at a discounted price.

Lucky Take-Out Surprise

$12.95
$12.95
Colorful product packaging for Handicorn unicorn finger puppet set featuring a hand with white unicorn head and hooves against a vibrant rainbow and starry sky background, with grass and daisies at the bottom

Handicorn - Unicorn Finger Puppet

$7.50
$7.50
Best Seller
Red circular tin of Emergency Googly Eyes with various sizes of adhesive plastic eyes scattered around, featuring a playful design of googly eyes on the lid

Emergency Googly Eyes

$8.00
$8.00
Best Seller
Red noisemaker device labeled "Disappointed Sigh" with buttons for different sigh types, shown in packaging and held in hand. Features cartoon of frustrated man and warning label. Humorous novelty product for expressing dismay electronically.

Disappointed Sigh

$11.95
$11.95
Best Seller
Novelty air freshener featuring a squirrel wearing white underpants, displayed in product packaging and as a standalone item. The squirrel has a tan body, bushy tail, and is standing upright. The packaging has a yellow background with acorn designs.

Squirrel in Underpants Air Freshener

$5.00
$5.00
Three Meditating Bigfoot figurines in brown, tan, and white colors, sitting cross-legged with eyes closed. Text above reads "MEDITATING BIGFOOT" in bold yellow and orange letters with black outline.

Meditating Bigfoot

$3.95
$3.95
Best Seller
Goth Cats vinyl figurines featuring four unique designs: emo cat with leather jacket, bat-winged black cat, vampire cat in cape, and skeleton cat. Green gothic-style text reads "GOTH CATS" above the figurines.

Goth Cats

$4.50
$4.50
Itty Bitty Rubber Chickens pack of 12 small yellow toy chickens in clear packaging, featuring fun and hilarious miniature designs for gag gifts or party favors

Itty Bitty Rubber Chickens

$11.25
$11.25
Yodelling Pickle

Yodelling Pickle

$15.00
$15.00
Best Seller
Yellow plush rubber chicken wearing red emotional support vest, standing upright with long neck and orange beak. Product tag shows "Emotional Support Chicken" with cartoon chicken face and "Squawk!" text. Comical and whimsical design for stress relief and companionship.

Emotional Support Chicken

$17.50
$17.50
Green tin of Archie McPhee Pickle Candy featuring a smiling cartoon pickle character. The tin contains individually wrapped green and white striped hard candies resembling pickles, showcasing the unique pickle-flavored confection.

Pickle Candy in Tin

$8.25
$8.25
Emergency Goat Sounds noisemaker with four buttons for different goat sounds, shown in packaging and held in hand. Colorful product design featuring cartoon goat and farm background.

Emergency Goat Sounds

$13.75
$13.75
Colorful assortment of whimsical finger monsters with bulging eyes and exaggerated features, displayed on fingertips against a vibrant blue background. Variety of shapes, sizes, and expressions showcasing the product's playful and quirky nature.

Deluxe Finger Monsters

$16.00
$16.00
Red tin box of Bacon Candy with pig illustration, containing individually wrapped red and white striped candies. Open tin displays candies, closed tin lid visible. Unique bacon-flavored hard candies in vintage-style packaging.

Bacon Candy in Tin

$8.25
$8.25
Red tin of Instant Underpants by Archie McPhee with 'Just Add Water!' text, next to a white compressed pellet of disposable underpants

Instant Underpants

$6.95
$6.95
Finger Cat Paws: Latex finger puppets resembling cat legs, shown worn on hands framing a surprised-looking gray cat. Product title in green text arches above the image.

Finger Cat Paws

$4.95
$4.95
Miniature vinyl feet accessories for fingers, shown on a hand against a white background with orange "Finger Feet" logo text

Finger Feet - Light Skin Tone

$3.95
$3.95
Inflatable Turkey novelty product with packaging and inflated turkey replica, perfect for Thanksgiving decoration or pranks, 16 inches long, realistic golden-brown appearance

Inflatable Turkey

$16.25
$16.25
Whimsical toy featuring a smiling possum driving a peanut-shaped car with wheels. The text "Possum in a Peanut" arches over the image. Unique children's pull-back toy made of vinyl and plastic, 5 inches long, perfect for imaginative play.

Possum in a Peanut

$12.50
$12.50