FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Set of four black and white rubber finger monsters with quirky designs, including multiple eyes, tentacle-like arms, and exaggerated features, perfect for creative play and nostalgic noir-style puppet shows.

Black and White Finger Monsters

$4.95
$4.95
Two red lobster claw finger puppets on human fingers, with "FINGER CLAWS" text above in bold red lettering. Realistic 3D design of lobster claws, showcasing playful and eye-catching novelty product for seafood enthusiasts and party-goers.

Finger Lobster Claws

$4.50
$4.50
Cat-shaped wine stopper in black silicone, packaged in clear box with green bottle, labeled 'Stop Kitty' for sealing and preserving wine bottles

Cat Wine Stopper

$12.95
$12.95
Squishy Bigfoot BFF toy in packaging and standalone, showing brown fuzzy creature with friendly smile and large feet, set against forest background with trees and birds

Squishy Bigfoot BFF

$14.95
$14.95
Jingle Butts Christmas ornaments: red and green glass baubles shaped like backsides, with tiny bells attached. Displayed hanging and in clear packaging, these humorous decorations add a cheeky twist to holiday decor.

Jingle Butts Ornaments

$23.95
$23.95
$23.95
Set of three Krampus Christmas buttons featuring colorful designs: a black horned figure on red, a green-background Krampus with basket, and a black-background Krampus face with gothic text. Festive and folkloric holiday accessories.

Krampus Christmas Buttons

$4.50
$4.50
Aromatic Mushroom Air Freshener featuring a realistic red and white spotted mushroom design, displayed in packaging and as a hanging product. Enchanting forest background on the package with glowing fireflies and grass.

Aromatic Mushroom Air Freshener

$3.95
$3.95
Bag of 8 tiny pink and white axolotl toys with red gills, packaged in clear plastic with green leafy background. Product image shows both packaged and unpackaged miniature vinyl axolotls for size reference.

Itty Bitty Axolotls - Bag of 8

$8.95
$8.95
Itty Bitty Bigfoot toy set featuring 8 miniature Sasquatch figurines, each standing on a small base. Packaging shows forest-themed design with Bigfoot silhouette. Tiny brown Bigfoot figures displayed in various walking poses.

Itty Bitty Bigfoot - Bag of 8

$8.95
$8.95
Yellow rubber chicken stress toy with comical face, red comb and feet, next to blue circular product packaging featuring "Stress Rubber Chicken" text and warning label

Stress Rubber Chicken

$7.50
$7.50
Green and yellow tin of Sour Cream & Onion Candy with cartoon onion and sour cream characters. Two striped candies in foreground. Product weight and brand name visible on tin.

Sour Cream & Onion Candy in Tin

$5.95
$5.95
Collection of colorful mini mushroom figurines in a display box, featuring eight different species with scientific names. Includes vibrant red, blue, yellow, and green mushrooms of various shapes and sizes, arranged both in and outside the packaging.

Collection of Mini Mushrooms

$14.95
$14.95
Sale
Introvert Ornament featuring a figure reading a book, packaged in a clear cylindrical container with snowflake designs and red accents. The ornament depicts a person with glasses immersed in reading, embodying the introvert theme.

Introvert Ornament

$7.95
$7.95
$14.95
Giant plastic ant toys in black, orange, and brown displayed in and outside a clear box with 'ANTS!' text, perfect for pranks and decorative fun

Ants!

$7.95
$7.95
Sale
Gertrude Ornament from J.P. Patches Show, featuring colorful glass figurine with pink hair, silver crown, and polka dot dress. Displayed both as hanging ornament and in clear packaging labeled 'Gertrude Ornament'. Vibrant collectible for fans of Seattle's beloved children's TV program.

Gertrude Ornament

$7.99
$7.99
$14.95
Cat-shaped tea infuser hanging on clear glass cup filled with orange tea. Gray silicone cat figure rests on cup rim, its body submerged in the tea as an infuser.

Purr Tea Tea Infuser

$13.95
$13.95
Sale
Colorful product packaging for "It's Your Lucky Day! Good Luck Kit" featuring horseshoe, rainbow, floating money, pot of gold, and clovers. Designed to bring luck and excitement for a fun, fortune-filled experience.

It's Your Lucky Day! Good Luck Kit

$5.95
$5.95
$11.95
Box of Jalapeño Candy Canes featuring red and green striped candy canes, with a cartoon jalapeño character holding a candy cane. The packaging displays the product name and cartoon peppers, blending Christmas and spicy themes.

Jalapeño Candy Canes

$6.95
$6.95
Handiclaus finger puppet set featuring Santa's head, hands, and boots on a real hand, with blue text logo above. Fun Christmas novelty toy for interactive play and storytelling.

Handiclaus

$7.50
$7.50
New
Best Seller
The Cryptids USA box includes five cryptid figures, featuring Bigfoot and the Flatwoods Monster, with a forest-themed design. It's a must-have for enthusiasts of America's legendary monsters.

Cryptids USA

$9.95
$9.95
Surprise Popping Possum toy with cute gray possum emerging from a small trash can-shaped container held in a hand, featuring product title in playful blue text

Surprise Popping Possum

$8.95
$8.95
Glass ornament featuring a woman in pink robe and glasses with small cat figures, shown hanging and in packaging labeled 'Crazy Cat Lady Ornament

Crazy Cat Lady® Ornament

$16.95
$16.95
Pine-flavored Bigfoot Candy Canes in green and white stripes, displayed in a festive box with Bigfoot illustrations holding a candy cane, perfect for unique Christmas treats

Bigfoot Candy Canes

$6.95
$6.95
Set of 5 green vinyl pickle-shaped finger coverings on an open hand, with "PICKLE FINGERS" text overlay in green 3D lettering, perfect for novelty costume accessories or playful kitchen decor

Pickle Fingers - Set of 5

$7.50
$7.50