FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Whimsical toy featuring a blue pigeon driving a peanut-shaped car. The peanut is tan with wheels, and the pigeon is visible through the top, holding a steering wheel. Text above reads "Pigeon in a Peanut" in stylized lettering.

Pigeon in a Peanut

$10.95
$10.95
Pack of 12 glow-in-the-dark dog figurines in various breeds and poses, arranged on white background with orange 'GLOW DOGS' text above. Small, soft vinyl toys for collectors or play, approximately 1.5 inches each, glowing green color.

Pack of Glow Dogs (Set of 12)

$9.50
$9.50
Glow-in-the-dark alien finger hands, green with elongated fingers, worn on human fingers. Text reads 'glow-in-the-dark alien finger hands' in blue and green letters.

Glow-in-the-Dark Alien Finger Hands - Set of 10

$13.95
$13.95
$0.00
Set of five colorful rubber chickens in red, blue, green, purple, and yellow, arranged in a row beneath vibrant text reading "Rainbow Rubber Chickens

Rainbow Rubber Chickens - Set of 5

$4.95
$4.95
Set of four adorable raccoon finger puppets in different shades, shown on a hand with product title "Finger Raccoons" above, perfect for playful storytelling and imaginative play

Finger Raccoons - Set of 4 Raccoon Finger Puppets

$7.95
$7.95
New
Green frog toy with packaging featuring flowers and 'Splat Frog' branding.

Splat Frog

$18.50
$18.50
Sale
Colorful toy tardigrades in blue and green, packaged in a clear bag with underwater-themed label. Set of 12 small, soft vinyl figures representing microscopic water bears, each about 1 inch long.

Itty Bitty Tardigrades - Bag of 12

$7.40
$7.40
$9.25
Hand making peace sign with gray brain-shaped finger puppets on index and middle fingers, above colorful "FINGER BRAINS" text label

Finger Brains - Set of 2

$3.50
$3.50
Bendable yellow rubber chicken toy with red comb and feet, shown both as standalone and in packaging with barn backdrop. Product titled "Bendy Rubber Chicken" on blue circular label.

Bendy Rubber Chicken

$4.95
$4.95
Whimsical toy featuring a black crow sitting in a peanut-shaped car with wheels, titled "Crow in a Peanut" above. Novelty pull-back vehicle for playful bird and nut enthusiasts.

Crow in a Peanut

$10.95
$10.95
Sale
Set of 3 meerkat finger puppets in different shades, shown on a hand. Soft vinyl toys with smiling faces, 3.75 inches long. Product title "Finger Meerkats" in yellow text above the image.

Finger Meerkats - Set of 3 Meerkat Finger Puppets

$3.50
$3.50
$4.50
Sale
Bag of 12 tiny pink blobfish toys, 1.25 inches long, soft vinyl, displayed in packaging and scattered. Adorable grumpy marine creature replicas for collectors and enthusiasts. Not suitable for young children due to small parts.

Itty Bitty Blobfish - Bag of 12

$5.00
$5.00
$7.25
New
Best Seller
Camping Frogs set with four quirky vinyl frogs and a campfire, ready for a hilarious forest adventure.

Camping Frogs

$12.95
$12.95
Astronaut Neapolitan ice cream sandwich package featuring a space helmet with Earth view, reflecting an ice cream sandwich inside. Product displayed in freeze-dried, ready-to-eat space food packaging with American flag and weight details.

Astronaut Ice Cream Neapolitan Ice Cream Sandwich

$6.50
$6.50
Colorful set of Fantastic Finger Monsters toys, featuring various quirky monster designs with unique features like horns, multiple eyes, and tentacles. Each monster is brightly colored and designed to fit on a finger as a puppet.

Fantastic Finger Monsters - Set of 6

$11.95
$11.95
Squeaking green pickle toy with comical face and open mouth, next to product packaging featuring "Squeak Pickle" branding and cartoon pickle image. Novelty item for ages 3 and up by Archie McPhee.

Squeak Pickle

$12.95
$12.95
Set of four colorful rat finger puppets in gray, white, brown, and black, worn on fingertips. Green text 'FINGER RATS' above. Cute and playful animal toys for interactive fun.

Finger Rats

$7.95
$7.95
$0.00
Sale
Crazy Cat Lady embroidered patch packaging and product display, featuring a woman wearing a pink hat with the patch, holding a white cat, showcasing the patch's design with cartoon cats and a blonde woman icon

Crazy Cat Lady® Embroidered Patch

$2.50
$2.50
$4.95
Black tin of Astrology Candy featuring colorful stained glass design depicting mystical elements and bookshelves. Below, two individually wrapped candies with purple and blue stripes, showcasing the product's unique appearance.

Astrology Candy in Tin

$5.95
$5.95
New
Best Seller
Sale
The Itty Bitty Balloon Animals pack offers eight vibrant miniatures in red, blue, green, and yellow, featuring charming dogs and ducks—ideal for practicing clown skills or adding whimsy to any event.

Itty Bitty Balloon Animals - Bag of 8

$7.40
$7.40
$9.25
Set of four colorful cat figurines dressed as boy band members, including a fedora-wearing leader, in a retro-style packaging labeled 'Boy Band Cats: The World's Hottest Feline Sensation

Boy Band Cats

$14.95
$14.95
3D Hummingbird Air Freshener with lavender scent, featuring colorful packaging and a detailed hummingbird design. Product showcases vibrant tropical flowers and a lifelike green hummingbird air freshener with string for hanging.

3D Hummingbird Air Freshener

$4.95
$4.95
Set of three Rosie the Riveter themed notebooks featuring iconic World War II women's empowerment imagery, including "We Can Do It!" slogan, working women, and inspirational quotes, perfect for writing goals and self-care reminders

Rosie the Riveter Notebooks

$6.95
$6.95
Black vinyl goat finger puppet with red eyes and horns, worn on a finger, creepy and demonic appearance for Halloween or dark humor, 2 inches tall, soft material

Baaad Finger Goat - Goat Finger Puppet

$2.95
$2.95
$0.00