FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Sale
Black mustache-shaped Christmas ornament hanging from green pine tree branch, adding a whimsical and gentlemanly touch to holiday decor

Mustache Ornament

$5.99
$5.99
$7.50
Packaged set of 12 miniature black crow figurines in various poses, with product packaging showing sunset scene and warning label, displayed against white background

Itty Bitty Crows - Bag of 12

$8.95
$8.95
Miniature Ouija board with orange planchette, featuring alphabet, numbers, and intricate design on aged yellow background, enclosed in orange frame, perfect for tiny séances or novelty collectors

World’s Smallest Ouija

$7.95
$7.95
Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington twirly pencil with black and white design, featuring a spiral track and Jack figure topper, perfect for Gothic writing or sketching.

Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington Twirly Pencils - Set of 2

$4.95
$4.95
Pack of 12 glow-in-the-dark dog figurines in various breeds and poses, arranged on white background with orange 'GLOW DOGS' text above. Small, soft vinyl toys for collectors or play, approximately 1.5 inches each, glowing green color.

Pack of Glow Dogs (Set of 12)

$9.50
$9.50
Generic playing cards with minimalist design displayed in hand, featuring plain text labels on cards and a simple tin case with 'Generic Playing Cards' text

Generic Playing Cards

$6.95
$6.95
Colorful display box of Terrifying Finger Monsters toy set featuring assorted miniature rubber monster characters in vibrant colors, designed for finger puppet play, with warning label for choking hazard

Finger Monsters - Bulk Box

$64.95
$64.95
Hand making peace sign with gray brain-shaped finger puppets on index and middle fingers, above colorful "FINGER BRAINS" text label

Finger Brains - Set of 2

$3.50
$3.50
Bigfoot playing cards in decorative outdoor-themed tin box, featuring Bigfoot illustration on card backs. Scenic mountain landscape with lake in background. Perfect for camping and outdoor enthusiasts.

Bigfoot Playing Cards

$6.95
$6.95
Bigfoot-themed air freshener with colorful packaging and hanging card design, featuring a sasquatch walking in a forest landscape with mountains, UFO, and full moon in the background

I Believe in Bigfoot Air Freshener

$3.95
$3.95
Sale
Hipster mustache accessory shown on product packaging and modeled by person wearing sunglasses and cap, featuring thick black handlebar style mustache for ironic fashion statement

Hipster Mustache

$2.99
$2.99
$3.95
Glow-in-the-dark alien finger hands, green with elongated fingers, worn on human fingers. Text reads 'glow-in-the-dark alien finger hands' in blue and green letters.

Glow-in-the-Dark Alien Finger Hands - Set of 10

$13.95
$13.95
Purrrly Kitty stress relief toys: Yellow and gray cat-shaped squeezable foam figures in cardboard box. Product packaging shows clear plastic display with orange logo. Cats have wide eyes and cute expressions, designed for stress relief and easy storage.

Purrrly Kitty - Stress Cat in a Box

$12.95
$12.95
Black cat ornament with bat wings and fangs, sitting upright. Yellow eyes and pink inner ears. Cylindrical packaging with "Goth Cat Ornament" label visible. Hanging string attached for tree display.

Goth Cat Ornament

$16.95
$16.95
3D Crow Air Freshener packaging and product image. Cardboard box shows flying crow over winter landscape. Actual 3D crow-shaped air freshener with blackberry scent and hanging string visible next to box.

3D Crow Air Freshener

$4.95
$4.95
Set of four adorable raccoon finger puppets in different shades, shown on a hand with product title "Finger Raccoons" above, perfect for playful storytelling and imaginative play

Finger Raccoons - Set of 4 Raccoon Finger Puppets

$7.95
$7.95
Bendable yellow rubber chicken toy with red comb and feet, shown both as standalone and in packaging with barn backdrop. Product titled "Bendy Rubber Chicken" on blue circular label.

Bendy Rubber Chicken

$4.95
$4.95
Set of five colorful rubber chickens in red, blue, green, purple, and yellow, arranged in a row beneath vibrant text reading "Rainbow Rubber Chickens

Rainbow Rubber Chickens - Set of 5

$4.95
$4.95
Set of 3 meerkat finger puppets in different shades, shown on a hand. Soft vinyl toys with smiling faces, 3.75 inches long. Product title "Finger Meerkats" in yellow text above the image.

Finger Meerkats - Set of 3 Meerkat Finger Puppets

$5.95
$5.95
Metal tin of Generic Bandages by Archie McPhee, containing 15 large sterile strips labeled 'BANDAGE' in bold black text. Tin and bandages shown side-by-side on white background, with product details visible on container.

Generic Bandages

$5.95
$5.95
Set of four colorful rat finger puppets in gray, white, brown, and black, worn on fingertips. Green text 'FINGER RATS' above. Cute and playful animal toys for interactive fun.

Finger Rats

$7.95
$7.95
Sale
Artist Facial Hair set featuring exaggerated black mustache and goatee on product packaging with stylized face illustration against blue sky background

Artist Facial Hair

$3.99
$3.99
$4.95
Sold Out
Embroidered patch featuring stylized book spines in shades of blue and teal, with a smiling face in the center. Text at bottom reads "BOOK SMELLER" in white stitching. Square patch with black border.

Book Smeller Embroidered Patch

$6.50
$6.50
Bag of 12 tiny pink blobfish toys, 1.25 inches long, soft vinyl, displayed in packaging and scattered. Adorable grumpy marine creature replicas for collectors and enthusiasts. Not suitable for young children due to small parts.

Itty Bitty Blobfish - Bag of 12

$8.95
$8.95