FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Set of 3 Racing Roaches toy insects with pull-back mechanism, realistic design in brown and black colors, featuring wheels for fast movement. Product title "Racing Roaches" displayed in stylized green text above the toy images.

Racing Roaches - Set of 3

$12.50
$12.50
Pickle-shaped air freshener with dill scent, packaged in green and yellow design featuring sliced pickles. Product shown both in packaging and as standalone hanging freshener.

Pickle Air Freshener

$3.95
$3.95
Giant yellow wooden pencil with red eraser, held in hand, next to its clear packaging. Oversized writing instrument for novelty and functionality, perfect for big ideas and desk decor.

Giant Wooden Pencil

$7.95
$7.95
Archie McPhee Hot Dog Candy tin with colorful packaging featuring hot dog illustration, alongside red and white striped candies resembling miniature hot dogs

Hot Dog Candy in Tin

$5.95
$5.95
Sale
Set of three "Invasion of the Monster Women" notebooks featuring stylized cartoon monster women on dark blue backgrounds with bold yellow text. Designs include a flying creature, spider-like monster, and tentacled beast in dynamic poses.

Monster Women Notebooks

$3.99
$3.99
$7.95
Set of three black crow finger puppets on a hand, with wings spread in flying positions, under red text reading "Flying Finger Crows

Finger Crows - Set of 3 Crow Finger Puppets

$8.95
$8.95
Blue metal tin featuring cartoon sloth nurse bandages with free prize inside. Includes image of sloth in nurse uniform holding heart, with matching bandage design. Text promotes getting better at your own speed.

Sloth Nurse Bandages

$5.95
$5.95
Archie McPhee gift card design with orange logo, blue starry background, and text "Give the gift of awesome!" Perfect for quirky and unique gift-giving.

Super Awesome Gift Card

from $10.00
from $10.00
Holy Toast bread stamper with religious figure impression, alongside toasted bread slice featuring the stamped image

Holy Toast

$7.50
$7.50
Three colorful axolotl figurines in meditation poses: green, white, and pink. They sit cross-legged with hands together, eyes closed, and serene expressions. Text above reads "Meditating Axolotls" in pink lettering.

Meditating Axolotls

$3.95
$3.95
3D Bat Air Freshener with blood orange scent, featuring a brown bat-shaped hanging ornament and packaging displaying a spooky moonlit scene with flying bats and silhouetted trees against a purple sky

3D Bat Air Freshener

$4.95
$4.95
Chandelier 3D air freshener packaging and product image, featuring a luxurious gold and crystal chandelier design on a white background. Package shows a grand estate and vintage car, with "The Scent of Success" tagline.

Chandelier 3D Air Freshener

$3.95
$3.95
Bigfoot Finger Feet puppets on human fingers, with large text overlay. Brown, hairy miniature Sasquatch feet worn on fingertips, showcasing realistic toes and fur texture. Novelty product for cryptid enthusiasts and playful forest creature reenactments.

Bigfoot Finger Feet

$3.95
$3.95
Vintage-style poster for "Delinquents with Combs" featuring retro imagery alongside a modern switchblade comb product, showcasing both the nostalgic packaging and the actual metal and plastic comb in open and closed positions

Switchblade Comb

$6.95
$6.95
Sale
Handipanda finger puppet set packaging featuring a hand wearing panda-shaped puppets, surrounded by bamboo and floral designs, with product name and warning label

Handipanda - Panda Finger Puppet

$3.99
$3.99
$7.50
Miniature cornhole game set with two wooden boards featuring colorful graphics, small holes, and tiny bean bags in red, yellow, and blue, perfect for desktop or travel play

World’s Smallest Cornhole

$7.95
$7.95
Box of Gravy Candy Canes with brown and white stripes, featuring retro-style packaging and illustration. Six candy canes visible in green box with red trim. Unique holiday treat concept combining savory gravy flavor with traditional candy cane shape.

Gravy Candy Canes

$6.95
$6.95
Notebook cover with colorful decision wheel featuring unicorn actions, set against a fantasy landscape with rainbows, mountains, and unicorns. Title reads "What Would A Unicorn Do?

What Would A Unicorn Do? Notebook

$7.95
$7.95
Red knitted thumb hat worn on a thumbs-up hand gesture, with product packaging displaying "Thumb Hat" and benefits. Miniature novelty item for stylish and practical cold-thumb coverage.

Thumb Hat - Red

$2.95
$2.95
Handimonster finger puppet set featuring a blue cyclops monster head and four claw puppets transforming a hand into a playful creature, with vibrant yellow product title above

Handimonster

$7.50
$7.50
Li'l Devil's Trick of the Day prank collection featuring seven classic joke items including whoopee cushion, joy buzzer, nail through finger, trick candy, snapping gum, fake ketchup, and fly in ice cube, displayed on a circular card with individual items scattered around

Li'l Devil's Trick of the Day Prank Collection

$14.95
$14.95
Set of three Bigfoot-themed pocket journals with kraft covers featuring different Sasquatch designs, worldwide sightings map, and mountain landscapes. Includes an open journal showing a Bigfoot sketch and handwritten notes.

Bigfoot Pocket Journals

$7.95
$7.95
Finger Squirrels finger puppets set featuring four colorful vinyl squirrel toys in grey, tan, brown, and red, with the product name displayed in green curved text above

Finger Squirrels - Finger Puppets

$7.95
$7.95
Set of three circular buttons featuring a black and white portrait of a woman wearing glasses and a distinctive collar, with the word "dissent" prominently displayed on each button

Dissent Buttons

$4.50
$4.50