FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Set of four colorful pig finger puppets displayed on a hand, with yellow text reading "FINGER PIGS" arching above them. Puppets range from light pink to orange in color, each with distinct facial features and expressions.

Finger Pigs - Set of 4

$7.95
$7.95
3D Hummingbird Air Freshener with lavender scent, featuring colorful packaging and a detailed hummingbird design. Product showcases vibrant tropical flowers and a lifelike green hummingbird air freshener with string for hanging.

3D Hummingbird Air Freshener

$4.95
$4.95
Black vinyl goat finger puppet with red eyes and horns, worn on a finger, creepy and demonic appearance for Halloween or dark humor, 2 inches tall, soft material

Baaad Finger Goat - Goat Finger Puppet

$2.95
$2.95
Astronaut Neapolitan ice cream sandwich package featuring a space helmet with Earth view, reflecting an ice cream sandwich inside. Product displayed in freeze-dried, ready-to-eat space food packaging with American flag and weight details.

Astronaut Ice Cream Neapolitan Ice Cream Sandwich

$6.50
$6.50
Colorful set of Fantastic Finger Monsters toys, featuring various quirky monster designs with unique features like horns, multiple eyes, and tentacles. Each monster is brightly colored and designed to fit on a finger as a puppet.

Fantastic Finger Monsters - Set of 6

$11.95
$11.95
Set of four colorful cat figurines dressed as boy band members, including a fedora-wearing leader, in a retro-style packaging labeled 'Boy Band Cats: The World's Hottest Feline Sensation

Boy Band Cats

$14.95
$14.95
Set of four colorful axolotl finger puppets in yellow, purple, pink, and green worn on a hand, with "Finger Axolotls" text above. Cute, smiling cartoon-style amphibian toys for interactive play.

Finger Axolotls - Set of 4 Axolotl Finger Puppets

$7.95
$7.95
Box of Axolotls toy set featuring four cute vinyl figurines, two large and two small, in light pink and white colors. Product box displays tropical scene with colorful axolotl illustrations. Warning label visible for choking hazard.

Box of Axolotls - Family of 4

$9.50
$9.50
Set of 4 colorful goat finger puppets on a hand, featuring black, white, yellow, and black-and-white designs. Product title "FINGER GOATS" in bold red text above the image.

Finger Goats- Set of 4 Goat Finger Puppets

$7.95
$7.95
Krampus holiday card featuring anthropomorphic creature in green suit holding cane, with horns and long tongue, against red background. Text reads "Merry Krampus.

Merry Krampus Card

$5.50
$5.50
Vintage Lord of the Rings character pins featuring Bilbo, Samwise, and Aragorn from the 1978 animated movie. Colorful circular metal pins with character illustrations and names on banners.

Lord of the Rings Pins

$6.95
$6.95
Blue triangular felt pennant with white text "GEEK" and a brain icon, perfect for proudly displaying geek status or support, ideal for IT enthusiasts and tech-savvy individuals

Geek Pennant

$4.50
$4.50
Red bandanas featuring classic monster designs including Frankenstein's monster, vampire, werewolf, and mummy. Intricate patterns surround the monster faces on vibrant red fabric, perfect for Halloween enthusiasts or year-round monster fans.

Monster Bandana

$8.95
$8.95
Two smiling cartoon rats riding pizza slice-shaped toy cars, with "Rat Racers" text in red and yellow above. Playful pull-back racers for kids, combining fun food and animal themes in a unique, whimsical design.

Rat Racers - Set of 2

$10.95
$10.95
Sold Out
Bigfoot Lip Balm tube featuring colorful illustration of Bigfoot walking in mountain landscape, with product name and vitamin information visible

Bigfoot Lip Balm

$3.95
$3.95
Best Seller
Crowned Critters logo with four royal forest creatures: a green frog, yellow snail, brown spider, and green snake, each wearing a golden crown. Colorful vinyl toys for playful decoration and collectibles.

Crowned Critters

$3.95
$3.95
Strawberry-scented Stress Werewolf foam toy with fierce facial features, orange fur, and green eyes, alongside product packaging showing werewolf transformation and warning label

Stress Werewolf

$4.95
$4.95
Bigfoot can cooler set featuring two designs: one with a walking Bigfoot silhouette against a mountain backdrop, and another with "I saw Bigfoot at Archie McPhee Seattle, USA" text, both on light blue foam koozies for beverages.

Bigfoot Can Cooler

$4.95
$4.95
Bag of 12 miniature vinyl hands in diverse skin tones, packaged in clear plastic with blue-labeled header, displayed with hands arranged below package showcasing various gestures and colors

Itty Bitty Hands - Bag of 12

$8.95
$8.95
Set of 3 brown bat finger puppets on hand, with outstretched wings, demonstrating mid-flight pose. Text "FINGER BATS" appears above in large, stylized lettering.

Finger Bats - Set of 3 Bat Finger Puppets

$7.50
$7.50
Santa Bigfoot action figure with brown fur, wearing a red and white Santa hat, standing upright in mid-stride pose, resembling the famous Patterson film footage. Articulated vinyl toy perfect for Christmas decorations or Sasquatch enthusiasts.

Santa Bigfoot Action Figure

$15.50
$15.50
Sold Out
Furrybones Whally Narwhal figurine featuring a smiling skeleton in a light blue narwhal costume with a spiral horn, holding a small purple unicorn toy, set against a white background

Furrybones Whally Narwhal

$14.99
$14.99
Beige nose finger puppet on index finger with blue text "NOSE FINGER PUPPETS" against white background, showcasing novelty toy product for Shopify store

Nose Finger Puppet

$1.50
$1.50
Set of four Racing Cats in Sacks toys, featuring beige-colored plastic cubes with cat tails and legs protruding, simulating cats inside bags. Red and white logo banner above displaying "Racing Cats in Sacks" text.

Racing Cats in Sacks - Set of 4

$19.95
$19.95