FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Bibo enamel pin featuring a quirky peach-colored character with large ears, three eyes, and a wide grin. Unique collectible accessory for Bibo fans.

Bibo Enamel Pin

$7.95
$7.95
Four circular buttons featuring classic monster faces: werewolf, Frankenstein's monster, female vampire, and male vampire. Each button has a black background with the monster's face in vivid colors and distinctive features, creating a spooky yet fun Halloween-themed set.

Monster Buttons - Set of Four

$5.95
$5.95
Glow-in-the-dark skeleton finger hands worn on two fingers, displaying bony structures. Text above reads 'GLOW-IN-THE-DARK SKELETON FINGER HANDS' in green and white lettering against a white background.

Glow-in-the-Dark Skeleton Finger Hands - Set of 2

$4.50
$4.50
Santaur Enamel Pin

Santaur Enamel Pin

$7.95
$7.95
Set of four colorful gecko finger puppets in blue, green, brown, and gray displayed on a hand, with "FINGER GECKOS" text above. Soft vinyl toys for imaginative play and fun.

Finger Geckos - Set of 4 Gecko Finger Puppets

$7.95
$7.95
New
Best Seller
Blue tin container of Archie McPhee's Possum Flavored Candy with orange lid, featuring cartoon possums and product details. Two pink and white striped candies displayed in front of the tin.

Possum Candy

$5.95
$5.95
Bulk box of mini finger hands for finger hands, featuring colorful display with hand illustrations and product information. Shows miniature hands on pencil tips and larger hand with tiny hands on fingers.

Finger Hands for Finger Hands Bulk Box

$74.95
$74.95
New
Itty Bitty Cats toy set featuring 12 miniature vinyl cat figurines in various playful poses, displayed in a clear bag with colorful packaging. Includes orange and black cats in different positions, perfect for collectors and cat lovers.

Itty Bitty Cats - Bag of 12

$8.95
$8.95
Glass mushroom ornament with red spotted cap and white stem in meditation pose, displayed in green-topped packaging and shown hanging with golden string

Meditating Mushroom Ornament

$16.95
$16.95
Colorful miniature whale toys in various shades of blue and black, with water sprays from blowholes. Eight small vinyl whales displayed outside packaging, showing product variety. Packaging visible with "Itty Bitty Whales" branding and quantity information.

Itty Bitty Whales - Bag of 8

$8.95
$8.95
Strange Pins enamel pin featuring a green-haired creature with bat wings and a pink outfit, displayed on packaging with a checkered background and question mark design

Monster Woman Enamel Pin

$7.95
$7.95
Sold Out
Furrybones Octopee Octopus figurine, featuring a smiling skeleton head in a purple octopus costume with tentacles, holding a small teal fish. The collectible has a whimsical, macabre design combining cute and spooky elements, perfect for unique decor.

Furrybones Octopee Octopus

$14.99
$14.99
Crowned Critters logo with four royal forest creatures: a green frog, yellow snail, brown spider, and green snake, each wearing a golden crown. Colorful vinyl toys for playful decoration and collectibles.

Crowned Critters

$4.95
$4.95
Pink axolotl air freshener with strawberry scent, displayed in packaging and as a hanging product. Cartoon-style amphibian with frilly gills, smiling face, and upright posture. Aquatic-themed background with teal colors and underwater plants.

Axolotl Air Freshener

$3.95
$3.95
Sold Out
Adorable Baby Worm toy in miniature white baby carriage, featuring a reddish-brown worm peeking out from the stroller against a soft pink background. Unique and whimsical product for children or collectors.

Baby Worm

$6.95
$6.95
Set of 4 colorful pigeon finger puppets perched on fingertips of an open hand, with orange feet and varied body colors including blue, pink, and white. Text "Finger Pigeons" appears above in orange curved letters.

Finger Pigeons - Set of 4 Pigeon Finger Puppets

$11.95
$11.95
Cute sloth-shaped tea infuser held over a white mug with inspirational text. The silicone sloth has perforations for steeping tea and is being gently gripped by a human hand, demonstrating its use as a unique and whimsical tea steeper.

Slow Brew Sloth Tea Infuser

$13.95
$13.95
Colorful cartoon wind-up Bigfoot toy with brown fur and smiling face, standing beneath bold orange text reading "Wind-Up Walking Bigfoot

Wind-Up Bigfoot

$7.50
$7.50
Set of four colorful hummingbird finger puppets on a hand, featuring vibrant designs with spread wings in various poses. Product title "Finger Hummingbirds" displayed above the image.

Finger Hummingbirds - Set of 4 Hummingbird Finger Puppets

$11.95
$11.95
Fuzzy brown notebook with "BIGFOOT" text and footprint design, held by a furry hand, simulating Bigfoot's appearance for a unique and tactile writing experience.

Fuzzy Bigfoot Notebook

$14.95
$14.95
3D Blue Jay Air Freshener packaging and product display, featuring a vibrant blue jay in flight. Package shows colorful landscape backdrop. Actual air freshener is a detailed, suspended 3D blue jay model with outstretched wings. Blueberry scent advertised.

3D Blue Jay Air Freshener

$4.95
$4.95
Rubber Chicken Museum lip balm tube featuring black label with yellow text and red chicken logo, from Seattle's Archie McPhee store, huckleberry flavored, 1-3/4 inches long

Rubber Chicken Museum Lip Balm

$3.95
$3.95
New
Set of four colorful cat figurines dressed as boy band members, including a fedora-wearing leader, in a retro-style packaging labeled 'Boy Band Cats: The World's Hottest Feline Sensation

Boy Band Cats

$15.95
$15.95
Assorted 3D lenticular cards featuring adorable animals including cats, dogs, horses, rabbits, and dolphins in vibrant, colorful settings. The cards showcase various sizes and cute animal poses, perfect for decorating or gifting.

Cute and Cuddly Lenticular Card Set

$9.95
$9.95