FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

New
Best Seller
Cheerful soft vinyl rain frogs with party hats and accessories are playfully posed in front of the Party Frogs box.

Party Frogs

$9.95
$9.95
Possum in a Peanut Air Freshener product image showing cartoon possum driving peanut-shaped car, with packaging displaying city skyline background. Cherry-scented, humorous car accessory for unique odor control and whimsical decoration.

Possum in a Peanut Air Freshener

$3.95
$3.95
Colorful miniature cactus toys in resealable package, featuring eight different small vinyl cacti with vibrant flowers in terracotta pots, perfect for collectors and decoration enthusiasts seeking realistic desert plant replicas

Itty Bitty Cactus - Bag of 8

$8.95
$8.95
New
Vinyl and plastic toy cats, designed to resemble loaves of bread on wheels, speed along beneath the Racing Bread Loaf Cats label.

Racing Bread Loaf Cats - Set of 4

$15.95
$15.95
Colorful cartoon wind-up Bigfoot toy with brown fur and smiling face, standing beneath bold orange text reading "Wind-Up Walking Bigfoot

Wind-Up Bigfoot

$5.95
$5.95
Strange Pins enamel pin featuring a green-haired creature with bat wings and a pink outfit, displayed on packaging with a checkered background and question mark design

Monster Woman Enamel Pin

$4.95
$4.95
Assortment of 12 miniature black cat figurines in various playful poses, packaged in a clear bag with product label showcasing larger cat silhouette. Cats range from sitting to stretching, with detailed textures visible on their tiny forms.

Itty Bitty Black Cats - Bag of 12

$8.95
$8.95
Set of 4 colorful pigeon finger puppets perched on fingertips of an open hand, with orange feet and varied body colors including blue, pink, and white. Text "Finger Pigeons" appears above in orange curved letters.

Finger Pigeons - Set of 4 Pigeon Finger Puppets

$9.95
$9.95
3D Blue Jay Air Freshener packaging and product display, featuring a vibrant blue jay in flight. Package shows colorful landscape backdrop. Actual air freshener is a detailed, suspended 3D blue jay model with outstretched wings. Blueberry scent advertised.

3D Blue Jay Air Freshener

$3.95
$3.95
Sold Out
Cute sloth-shaped tea infuser held over a white mug with inspirational text. The silicone sloth has perforations for steeping tea and is being gently gripped by a human hand, demonstrating its use as a unique and whimsical tea steeper.

Slow Brew Sloth Tea Infuser

$13.95
$13.95
Squishy Armadillo toy with textured shell in packaging and hand demonstrating its squeezable nature, perfect for fidgeting and stress relief

Squishy Armadillo

$11.95
$11.95
Sold Out
Rubber Chicken Museum lip balm tube featuring black label with yellow text and red chicken logo, from Seattle's Archie McPhee store, huckleberry flavored, 1-3/4 inches long

Rubber Chicken Museum Lip Balm

$3.95
$3.95
Set of four colorful hummingbird finger puppets on a hand, featuring vibrant designs with spread wings in various poses. Product title "Finger Hummingbirds" displayed above the image.

Finger Hummingbirds - Set of 4 Hummingbird Finger Puppets

$9.95
$9.95
Furrybones Octopee Octopus figurine, featuring a smiling skeleton head in a purple octopus costume with tentacles, holding a small teal fish. The collectible has a whimsical, macabre design combining cute and spooky elements, perfect for unique decor.

Furrybones Octopee Octopus

$14.99
$14.99
Whimsical yellow rubber chicken tea infuser floating in a clear glass mug filled with amber-colored tea, showcasing its unique design and perforated body for steeping

Cock-A-Doodle Brew Tea infuser

$13.95
$13.95
Fuzzy brown notebook with "BIGFOOT" text and footprint design, held by a furry hand, simulating Bigfoot's appearance for a unique and tactile writing experience.

Fuzzy Bigfoot Notebook

$14.95
$14.95
Sold Out
Grim Steeper tea infuser shaped like Death, with skull face and scythe, steeping in clear glass mug filled with golden tea. Unique and humorous kitchen accessory for tea lovers and Halloween enthusiasts.

Grim Steeper Tea Infuser

$13.95
$13.95
Assorted 3D lenticular cards featuring adorable animals including cats, dogs, horses, rabbits, and dolphins in vibrant, colorful settings. The cards showcase various sizes and cute animal poses, perfect for decorating or gifting.

Cute and Cuddly Lenticular Card Set

$9.95
$9.95
Set of 4 colorful vulture finger puppets on a hand, featuring realistic details and varied poses. Soft vinyl toys for playful scavenging fun, suitable for adults. Product image showcases diverse designs and lifelike appearance of the Finger Vultures set.

Finger Vultures - Set of 4 Vulture Finger Puppets

$9.95
$9.95
Itty Bitty Werewolves - Bag of 9 miniature vinyl figures in various poses, packaged in illustrated bag with moonlit werewolf silhouette. Product image shows small brown werewolf figurines with blue bases, perfect for collectors and Halloween enthusiasts.

Itty Bitty Werewolves - Bag of 9

$8.95
$8.95
New
Two serene cacti adorned with flower crowns in orange pots are positioned underneath the title Meditating Cactus, capturing a meditative essence.

Meditating Cactus

$4.50
$4.50
Glow-in-the-dark finger monster toys displayed in a colorful box with whimsical monster illustrations on top, showcasing various rubber monster finger puppets in different shapes and colors

Glow-in-the-Dark Finger Monsters - Bulk Box

$64.95
$64.95
Black leather passport cover with gold lettering featuring "Pressed Penny Passport" and an illustration of a possum driving a peanut-shaped car, titled "Possum Adventure" for storing collectible pressed pennies

Possum in a Peanut Pressed Penny Passport

$9.95
$9.95
Colorful display box of Rainbow Finger Hands toys, featuring tiny rubber hands in various colors that fit on fingertips. Product packaging shows vibrant red, yellow, blue, green, and purple miniature hands arranged in a retail display container.

Rainbow Finger Hands Bulk Box

$79.95
$79.95