FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Stocking Stuffers

The Cryptids USA box includes five cryptid figures, featuring Bigfoot and the Flatwoods Monster, with a forest-themed design. It's a must-have for enthusiasts of America's legendary monsters.

Cryptids USA

$12.50
$12.50
Colorful meditating squid toys in pink, blue, and green, sitting in yoga poses under bold "Meditating Squid" text logo, perfect for mindfulness enthusiasts and quirky decor lovers

Meditating Squid

$4.50
$4.50
Jingle Butts Christmas ornaments: red and green glass baubles shaped like backsides, with tiny bells attached. Displayed hanging and in clear packaging, these humorous decorations add a cheeky twist to holiday decor.

Jingle Butts Ornaments

$23.95
$23.95
$23.95
Sale
Handimonster finger puppet set featuring a blue cyclops monster head and four claw puppets transforming a hand into a playful creature, with vibrant yellow product title above

Handimonster

$4.75
$4.75
$5.95
Surprise Popping Alley Cat toy featuring orange, black, and gray cats in mini trash cans. Hand demonstrating pop-up action with orange cat. Product title in green text. Novelty gift for cat lovers and pranksters.

Surprise Popping Alley Cat

$11.25
$11.25
Set of three Bigfoot-themed pocket journals with kraft covers featuring different Sasquatch designs, worldwide sightings map, and mountain landscapes. Includes an open journal showing a Bigfoot sketch and handwritten notes.

Bigfoot Pocket Journals

$6.95
$6.95
Pine-flavored Bigfoot Candy Canes in green and white stripes, displayed in a festive box with Bigfoot illustrations holding a candy cane, perfect for unique Christmas treats

Bigfoot Candy Canes

$9.50
$9.50
Box of Jalapeño Candy Canes featuring red and green striped candy canes, with a cartoon jalapeño character holding a candy cane. The packaging displays the product name and cartoon peppers, blending Christmas and spicy themes.

Jalapeño Candy Canes

$9.50
$9.50
New
The Merry Christmas Frogs set features four festive vinyl frog figurines in holiday outfits, displayed in front of a cheerful holiday-themed box.

Merry Christmas Frogs

$15.00
$15.00
Rubber chicken wine stopper 'Coq au Vin' by Fred in packaging, featuring yellow silicone chicken body with raised wings and red feet, inserted into white wine bottle neck for humorous wine preservation

Rubber Chicken Wine Stopper

$14.95
$14.95
New
Best Seller
The product packaging of Opera Corn showcases a singing corn on the cob with a speech bubble exclaiming Figaro Figaro in operatic sounds.

Opera Corn

$15.00
$15.00
Set of three circular buttons featuring a black and white portrait of a woman wearing glasses and a distinctive collar, with the word "dissent" prominently displayed on each button

Dissent Buttons

$4.50
$4.50
Stress Possum toy with packaging, featuring a beige foam possum head with pink nose and mouth, alongside circular product label showing possum face and 'Stress Possum' text on blue background

Stress Possum

$5.95
$5.95
Best Seller
Cleaning Cat Air Freshener with orange-scented cartoon cat in grooming pose, packaged and as hanging cardstock cutout, for car odor control

Cleaning Cat Air Freshener

$5.00
$5.00
New
Pacific Northwest Salmon Candy Canes box with six striped orange and white candy canes and a cartoon salmon holding one in its mouth

Pacific Northwest Salmon Candy Canes

$9.50
$9.50
Squishy Bigfoot BFF toy in packaging and standalone, showing brown fuzzy creature with friendly smile and large feet, set against forest background with trees and birds

Squishy Bigfoot BFF

$15.95
$15.95
Finger Hands display box showcasing miniature rubber hands in various skin tones. Blue packaging with product name and slogan "The little hands that go hand in hand with your hand". Multiple tiny hands visible inside and illustrated on box.

Finger Hands - Bulk Box

$144.00
$144.00
Set of four black and white rubber finger monsters with quirky designs, including multiple eyes, tentacle-like arms, and exaggerated features, perfect for creative play and nostalgic noir-style puppet shows.

Black and White Finger Monsters

$4.95
$4.95
Green and yellow tin of Sour Cream & Onion Candy with cartoon onion and sour cream characters. Two striped candies in foreground. Product weight and brand name visible on tin.

Sour Cream & Onion Candy in Tin

$8.25
$8.25
Itty Bitty Bigfoot toy set featuring 8 miniature Sasquatch figurines, each standing on a small base. Packaging shows forest-themed design with Bigfoot silhouette. Tiny brown Bigfoot figures displayed in various walking poses.

Itty Bitty Bigfoot - Bag of 8

$11.25
$11.25
Two red metal tins featuring The Fly Widow Game, displaying a Victorian-era woman in black and white on a vibrant red background. The tins showcase the game title and tagline "Murder, Intrigue, Flies!

Fly Widow Game

$12.95
$12.95
Two red lobster claw finger puppets on human fingers, with "FINGER CLAWS" text above in bold red lettering. Realistic 3D design of lobster claws, showcasing playful and eye-catching novelty product for seafood enthusiasts and party-goers.

Finger Lobster Claws

$4.50
$4.50
Packaged set of 12 miniature black crow figurines in various poses, with product packaging showing sunset scene and warning label, displayed against white background

Itty Bitty Crows - Bag of 12

$11.25
$11.25
Best Seller
Blue tin container of Archie McPhee's Possum Flavored Candy with orange lid, featuring cartoon possums and product details. Two pink and white striped candies displayed in front of the tin.

Possum Candy in Tin

$8.25
$8.25