FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Sale
The Tiny Box of Snails showcases three bodaciously styled snail toys in orange and green, made from soft vinyl.

Tiny Box of Snails

$3.95
$3.95
$4.95
The Seahorse Air Freshener showcases seahorse-shaped packaging featuring a pink seahorse and emits a delightful strawberry fragrance.

Seahorse Air Freshener

$4.95
$4.95
New
Shrimp Back Scratcher with a telescopic orange handle and detailed prawn design for playful itch relief.

Shrimp Back Scratcher

$9.95
$9.95
New
Axolotl Back Scratcher with extendable handle and cute pink axolotl head for soothing hard-to-reach itches

Axolotl Back Scratcher

$9.95
$9.95
Sale
Box of three Tiny Box of Bigfoots figurines made from soft vinyl, includes a small parts warning label.

Tiny Box of Bigfoots

$3.95
$3.95
$4.95
New
Best Seller
Two colorful Finger Shrimp toys perched on fingers, ready to wiggle and skitter underwater fun.

Finger Shrimp

$6.50
$6.50
Finger Feet bulk box display with miniature rubber feet toys for fingers, showing packaging and product examples in various skin tones. Image showcases fun, novelty item for hands, perfect for creative play or tiny costumes.

Finger Feet - Bulk Box

$119.95
$119.95
Two vintage Catholic prayer cards depicting a priest at the altar with a crucifix, candles, and smaller figures below. Gold-edged, sepia-toned images with religious symbolism and 1937 printing details visible.

Holy Style Prayer Card

$4.95
$4.95
Furrybones Krampus figurine featuring skeletal creature in monster costume holding bundle of sticks, with small frightened child figure in basket, showcasing unique blend of cute and creepy holiday decor

Furrybones Krampus

$14.95
$14.95
New
Sale
Itty Bitty Goldfish - Bag of 10 tiny, soft vinyl orange fish, perfect for a fun school of memorable little fishies.

Itty Bitty Goldfish - Bag of 10

$7.40
$7.40
$9.25
Four pin-back buttons featuring bat cat, emo cat, caped vampire cat and skeleton cat each against a swirling gray and black background.

Goth Cat Buttons

$5.95
$5.95
New
Cryptid Bouncing Balls set featuring Bigfoot, Mothman, and Jersey Devil inside clear bouncy balls for cryptozoologist fun.

Cryptid Bouncing Balls

$11.95
$11.95
Bigfoot finger puppet sitting on raised index finger, with colorful text "BIGFOOT FINGER PUPPET" above. Brown, furry creature with large feet and expressive face. Fun, playful toy for Sasquatch enthusiasts.

Bigfoot Finger Puppet - Set of 3

$7.50
$7.50
Set of three realistic bald eagle finger puppets with spread wings on a hand making a peace sign, beneath text reading "FINGER EAGLES

Finger Eagles - Set of 3 Eagle Finger Puppets

$7.50
$7.50
Lenticular cards featuring majestic wildlife images including wolves, eagles, tigers, and leopards. Set of seven 3D cards with various sizes displaying rugged, masculine animal themes perfect for tilting and admiring.

Rough and Tumble Lenticular Card Set

$9.95
$9.95
Bulk box of Finger Cat Paws product, featuring playful cat-themed finger puppets that mimic cat legs. Display shows two cats and a human hand wearing the paw, with a blue yarn ball. Text reads "now... you're the cat!" Perfect for cat-related activities and fun.

Finger Cat Paws - Bulk Box

$72.95
$72.95
New
Foot Race - Set of 2 with funny foot racers on wheels for humorous racing fun and kicking back in style.

Foot Race - Set of 2

$4.95
$4.95
Sale
Miniature white picket fence toy in packaging, showing small fence pieces and assembled circular fence example. Product title and colorful suburban background visible on package.

Itty Bitty White Picket Fence

$5.80
$5.80
$7.25
New
Meditating Venus Flytrap toy in two colors, soft vinyl plant striking a funny meditative pose in tiny pots.

Meditating Venus Flytrap

$4.50
$4.50
Cute blue narwhal-shaped tea infuser perched on the rim of a glass mug filled with golden tea, its long tusk extending upwards and tail submerged in the beverage

Spiked Tea Narwhal Tea Infuser

$14.95
$14.95
Display box of Archie McPhee Finger Claws, showing bright red lobster claw-shaped finger puppets. Ocean-themed packaging with "Handy in a Pinch!" slogan, showcasing product in bulk quantity for parties or promotional events.

Finger Lobster Claws - Bulk Box

$39.95
$39.95
New
A hand inserts a dollar into the Orange Tabby Cat Coin Purse, ideal for cat lovers. The label, Orange Tabby Cat Coin Purse, perfectly captures feline enthusiasts charm.

Orange Tabby Cat Coin Purse

$12.95
$12.95
Five pin-back buttons featuring Jersey Devil, Chupacabra, Mothman, the Flatwoods Monster and Bigfoot each against a forest background.

Cryptid Creatures Buttons

$6.95
$6.95
Furrybones Bun Bun Lope figurine, skeleton in jackalope costume with antlers and brown fur, holding small purple unicorn doll, wearing green bowtie, sitting pose with pink paw pads visible

Furrybones Bun Bun Lope Jackalope

$14.99
$14.99