FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $50 • FREE GIFT WITH EVERY ORDER

Home | Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffers

Li'l Devil's Trick of the Day prank collection featuring seven classic joke items including whoopee cushion, joy buzzer, nail through finger, trick candy, snapping gum, fake ketchup, and fly in ice cube, displayed on a circular card with individual items scattered around

Li'l Devil's Trick of the Day Prank Collection

$14.95
$14.95
Finger Squirrels finger puppets set featuring four colorful vinyl squirrel toys in grey, tan, brown, and red, with the product name displayed in green curved text above

Finger Squirrels - Finger Puppets

$7.95
$7.95
Set of three circular buttons featuring a black and white portrait of a woman wearing glasses and a distinctive collar, with the word "dissent" prominently displayed on each button

Dissent Buttons

$4.50
$4.50
Finger Hands display box showcasing miniature rubber hands in various skin tones. Blue packaging with product name and slogan "The little hands that go hand in hand with your hand". Multiple tiny hands visible inside and illustrated on box.

Finger Hands - Bulk Box

$84.95
$84.95
Rubber chicken wine stopper 'Coq au Vin' by Fred in packaging, featuring yellow silicone chicken body with raised wings and red feet, inserted into white wine bottle neck for humorous wine preservation

Rubber Chicken Wine Stopper

$13.95
$13.95
Surprise Popping Alley Cat toy featuring orange, black, and gray cats in mini trash cans. Hand demonstrating pop-up action with orange cat. Product title in green text. Novelty gift for cat lovers and pranksters.

Surprise Popping Alley Cat

$9.95
$9.95
Groaning Blobfish stress toy with packaging, soft vinyl fish with grumpy expression, 7.25 inches long, makes oink-like sound when squeezed, perfect for expressing minor frustrations at work

Groaning Blobfish

$12.95
$12.95
Colorful meditating squid toys in pink, blue, and green, sitting in yoga poses under bold "Meditating Squid" text logo, perfect for mindfulness enthusiasts and quirky decor lovers

Meditating Squid

$4.95
$4.95
Emergency Monkey Sounds electronic device with four buttons for different monkey noises, shown in packaging and held in hand, featuring jungle-themed design and cartoon monkey illustrations

Emergency Monkey Sounds

$10.95
$10.95
Two red metal tins featuring The Fly Widow Game, displaying a Victorian-era woman in black and white on a vibrant red background. The tins showcase the game title and tagline "Murder, Intrigue, Flies!

Fly Widow Game

$12.95
$12.95
3D bee-shaped air freshener with honey scent, featuring detachable wings and colorful packaging. Product shown hanging and displayed against meadow backdrop. Unique car accessory for bee enthusiasts and nature lovers.

3D Bee Air Freshener

$4.95
$4.95
Glass pug head Christmas ornament with wrinkled face and pink tongue, shown hanging and in green-based packaging, capturing the breed's unique features for holiday decoration

Pug Head Ornament

$16.95
$16.95
Two red lobster claw finger puppets on human fingers, with "FINGER CLAWS" text above in bold red lettering. Realistic 3D design of lobster claws, showcasing playful and eye-catching novelty product for seafood enthusiasts and party-goers.

Finger Lobster Claws

$4.50
$4.50
Set of four black and white rubber finger monsters with quirky designs, including multiple eyes, tentacle-like arms, and exaggerated features, perfect for creative play and nostalgic noir-style puppet shows.

Black and White Finger Monsters

$4.95
$4.95
Stress Possum toy with packaging, featuring a beige foam possum head with pink nose and mouth, alongside circular product label showing possum face and 'Stress Possum' text on blue background

Stress Possum

$7.95
$7.95
Squishy Bigfoot BFF toy in packaging and standalone, showing brown fuzzy creature with friendly smile and large feet, set against forest background with trees and birds

Squishy Bigfoot BFF

$14.95
$14.95
Sale
Rosie the Riveter air freshener featuring iconic "We Can Do It!" image, lemon scented, in packaging. Empowering car accessory with vintage wartime poster design, showcasing strength and determination. Perfect for adding motivation and fresh scent to vehicles.

Rosie the Riveter Air Freshener

$1.99
$1.99
$3.50
Cat-shaped wine stopper in black silicone, packaged in clear box with green bottle, labeled 'Stop Kitty' for sealing and preserving wine bottles

Cat Wine Stopper

$12.95
$12.95
Set of three Krampus Christmas buttons featuring colorful designs: a black horned figure on red, a green-background Krampus with basket, and a black-background Krampus face with gothic text. Festive and folkloric holiday accessories.

Krampus Christmas Buttons

$4.50
$4.50
Emergency Crow Sounds electronic noisemaker with four buttons for different crow calls, shown in packaging and held in hand. Device features caw, rattle, angry, and murder sounds, with crow silhouette design on white plastic casing.

Emergency Crow Sounds

$10.95
$10.95
Yellow rubber chicken stress toy with comical face, red comb and feet, next to blue circular product packaging featuring "Stress Rubber Chicken" text and warning label

Stress Rubber Chicken

$7.50
$7.50
Dante's Inferno Candy Canes packaging with red and white striped canes, fiery logo, and illustration of medieval figure holding a candy cane. Product box displays six spicy holiday treats inspired by literary hell theme.

Dante's Inferno Candy Canes

$6.95
$6.95
Sale
Handages tin container with hand-shaped bandages displayed on blue backgrounds, showcasing unique design and different skin tones, perfect for quirky first aid solutions

Handages

$3.99
$3.99
$5.95
Sale
Gertrude Ornament from J.P. Patches Show, featuring colorful glass figurine with pink hair, silver crown, and polka dot dress. Displayed both as hanging ornament and in clear packaging labeled 'Gertrude Ornament'. Vibrant collectible for fans of Seattle's beloved children's TV program.

Gertrude Ornament

$7.99
$7.99
$14.95